Thursday, November 19, 2026

A 24-Team College Football Playoff Will Probably Suck

I'm generally a fan of a college football playoff (at least, it's a better way of determining a championship - the teams play for it on the field - than either the old jumbled-up bowl-and-polls system or the flawed and corrupt Bowl Championship Series), but I'm not sure how I feel about last week's announcement that the College Football Playoff would be expanding to 24 teams start next season.

I've always thought that an eight-team playoff made the most sense, but I've been happy with its current 12-team iteration. I'd even be amendable to a 16-team setup. But 24 teams just seems like too many. 

The fact is, there aren't 12 or 16 teams elite enough to compete for a national title, let alone 24. A 24-team playoff, in my opinion, would only be interesting if every FBS conference was awarded a berth, much like every conference gets a berth in the NCAA Basketball Tournament. This would potentially create compelling "cinderella" stories that sports fans love, and level the college football playing field by giving all of the "Group of Six" conference champions a (theoretical, at least) path to greatness. 

But, as Sam Khan Jr. demonstrates from the most recent CFP Committee rankings, that's probably not what we're going to get next season:

Indeed, Florida, Oklahoma and South Carolina are all four-loss SEC teams; the latter two aren't even ranked in the AP top 25. (Houston wouldn't deserve to be in the playoff either, after they shit the bed against Colorado last Friday.) Meanwhile, AP-ranked Group of Six teams like one-loss Liberty* and two-loss Memphis are on the outside looking in. 

Sure, teams like Memphis and Liberty probably won't compete for the national title. But neither will four-loss teams like Florida or South Carolina. They're included in the mix because they're "name" schools from a "name" conference that are expected to generate viewership (Florida and Oklahoma being two of the 18 teams that generate half of college football's viewership) and, hence, revenue. Which is, of course, what this playoff expansion is all about.

Mediocre SEC and Big Ten teams get into the playoff. They'll make money. ESPN will make money. The CFP Committee will make pretexts about "strength of schedule" as they pat each other on the back. Deserving Group of Six schools (aside from a single dedicated berth) will remain on the outside looking in. They won't make money. The gap between the "haves" and "have-nots" of college football will continue to widen.

Another by-product of a 24-team playoff is that conference championship games will go away. I can't say I'm too I'm upset about that because those stopped making sense when conferences stopped splitting themselves into divisions anyway. But I do feel bad for the bowls that are not part of the playoff, because it will be more difficult for them to cobble together compelling matchups from the remaining schools. And I also don't like the fact that a 24-team playoff will further diminish the importance of regular season games (this was one of the biggest arguments that people opposed to a playoff used to make). An 8- or 12-team playoff was small enough to preserve the gravity of the regular season. A 24-team playoff that includes four-loss schools does not.

It's honestly getting harder and harder for me to love college football. That'a not something I ever thought I'd say. But between conferences that make no geographic sense and that have killed long-standing rivalries, out-of-control payments to players via NIL, the transfer portal that makes players free agents every season, the non-stop coaching carousel (with ridiculous salaries to boot), and now a 24-team playoff that is certain to be dominated by the SEC and Big Ten schools regardless of merit, it feels like I'm inching closer to finding other things to do on my Saturdays in the fall.

Bill Connelly's misgivings about 24-team playoff are similar to mine. Tim Cowlishaw thinks this is the "worst postseason idea of all time."

* I have absolutely no love for the evangelical madrassa that is Liberty University, but that doesn't discount evident unfairness of the 24-team concept.

No comments: